Zoom/SoxNats argument

PatsNats09 · Admin Posts: 2673 Join date: 2008-08-21 Age: 16

You could franchise Ray Lewis...

_________________

Touchdown Jesus · Admin Posts: 2076 Join date: 2008-08-21

Lewis is the best player with a 1 year deal, Fins are one of the teams with GMs who didnt do their resignings...

_________________

PatsNats09 · Admin Posts: 2673 Join date: 2008-08-21 Age: 16

tra thomas is rated higher, he's 95

_________________

Touchdown Jesus · Admin Posts: 2076 Join date: 2008-08-21

SoxNats09 wrote:

tra thomas is rated higher, he's 95

Tra Thomas has yet to be signed by a team in real life

Ray Lewis just agreed to a juicy contract to stay with the Ravens and is still considered a top 3 MLB in the NFL

if you think Tra Thomas is more valuable you're crazy

_________________

PatsNats09 · Admin Posts: 2673 Join date: 2008-08-21 Age: 16

Touchdown Jesus wrote:

SoxNats09 wrote:

tra thomas is rated higher, he's 95

Tra Thomas has yet to be signed by a team in real life

Ray Lewis just agreed to a juicy contract to stay with the Ravens and is still considered a top 3 MLB in the NFL

if you think Tra Thomas is more valuable you're crazy

I didn't say that, I said he was rated higher Neutral

_________________

Touchdown Jesus · Admin Posts: 2076 Join date: 2008-08-21

SoxNats09 wrote:

Touchdown Jesus wrote:

SoxNats09 wrote:

tra thomas is rated higher, he's 95

Tra Thomas has yet to be signed by a team in real life

Ray Lewis just agreed to a juicy contract to stay with the Ravens and is still considered a top 3 MLB in the NFL

if you think Tra Thomas is more valuable you're crazy

I didn't say that, I said he was rated higher Neutral

that doesnt make him better or more valuable

_________________

PatsNats09 · Admin Posts: 2673 Join date: 2008-08-21 Age: 16

Touchdown Jesus wrote:

SoxNats09 wrote:

Touchdown Jesus wrote:

SoxNats09 wrote:

tra thomas is rated higher, he's 95

Tra Thomas has yet to be signed by a team in real life

Ray Lewis just agreed to a juicy contract to stay with the Ravens and is still considered a top 3 MLB in the NFL

if you think Tra Thomas is more valuable you're crazy

I didn't say that, I said he was rated higher Neutral

that doesnt make him better or more valuable

And btw, Thomas also signed a 3 year deal, with the Jags. And Thomas is a top LT in the league still IMO.

_________________

Touchdown Jesus · Admin Posts: 2076 Join date: 2008-08-21

SoxNats09 wrote:

And btw, Thomas also signed a 3 year deal, with the Jags.

cool, too bad he signed when it was no longer relevant

SoxNats09 wrote:

And Thomas is a top LT in the league still IMO.

Joe Thomas
Walter Jones
Matt Light
Jason Peters despite his off year
Michael Roos
Marcus McNeill
Ryan Clady
Jake Long
David Diehl
Flozell Adams
Bryant McKinnie
Jordan Gross
Mike Gandy

talent-wise, id take any and all of them over William Thomas... And 14th out of 32 teams doesn't qualify him as being a top LT in the league. If I included RTs that list would be even longer.

_________________

PatsNats09 · Admin Posts: 2673 Join date: 2008-08-21 Age: 16

Touchdown Jesus wrote:

SoxNats09 wrote:

And btw, Thomas also signed a 3 year deal, with the Jags.

cool, too bad he signed when it was no longer relevant

SoxNats09 wrote:

And Thomas is a top LT in the league still IMO.

Joe Thomas
Walter Jones
Matt Light
Jason Peters despite his off year
Michael Roos
Marcus McNeill
Ryan Clady
Jake Long
David Diehl
Flozell Adams
Bryant McKinnie
Jordan Gross
Mike Gandy

talent-wise, id take any and all of them over William Thomas... And 14th out of 32 teams doesn't qualify him as being a top LT in the league. If I included RTs that list would be even longer.

I disagree with you, some of the guys like Clady or Long have much more potential, but he's better right now, and other guys like Gandy and McKinnie aren't better. But whatever...

_________________

Touchdown Jesus · Admin Posts: 2076 Join date: 2008-08-21

SoxNats09 wrote:

Touchdown Jesus wrote:

SoxNats09 wrote:

And btw, Thomas also signed a 3 year deal, with the Jags.

cool, too bad he signed when it was no longer relevant

SoxNats09 wrote:

And Thomas is a top LT in the league still IMO.

Joe Thomas
Walter Jones
Matt Light
Jason Peters despite his off year
Michael Roos
Marcus McNeill
Ryan Clady
Jake Long
David Diehl
Flozell Adams
Bryant McKinnie
Jordan Gross
Mike Gandy

talent-wise, id take any and all of them over William Thomas... And 14th out of 32 teams doesn't qualify him as being a top LT in the league. If I included RTs that list would be even longer.

I disagree with you, some of the guys like Clady or Long have much more potential, but he's better right now, and other guys like Gandy and McKinnie aren't better. But whatever...

Broncos are a division rival, I know what im talking about, Clady was an absolute beast and didnt allow a sack for something like the first 9 games of the season, now factor in how the Broncos drop back to pass over 30 times/game. Based on last season hes top 5 on that list.

A coaching change is big, and the Dolphins certainly had a few good offseason moves, but dont think Jake Long didnt play a huge role in turning a 1-15 team into a division leader.

Gandy was a force all season long, the line was a HUUUUGE reason why the Cardinals made it to the SB, you cant contest Gandys talent especially when you put him against Thomas.

You could make an arguement with McKinnie, id still gladly take him over Thomas.

pulling 4 names out of a list of 13 still doesnt prove your point.

_________________

PatsNats09 · Admin Posts: 2673 Join date: 2008-08-21 Age: 16

They were just examples, I could go on... do you want me to?

_________________

Mr.Showtime · Posts: 950 Join date: 2008-10-04 Age: 18

This is not the topic to argue, duders.

Touchdown Jesus · Admin Posts: 2076 Join date: 2008-08-21

SoxNats09 wrote:

They were just examples, I could go on... do you want me to?

yes and instead of just naming off random players (which anyone can do) actually give proof that theyre worse.

_________________

PatsNats09 · Admin Posts: 2673 Join date: 2008-08-21 Age: 16

Touchdown Jesus wrote:

SoxNats09 wrote:

They were just examples, I could go on... do you want me to?

yes and instead of just naming off random players (which anyone can do) actually give proof that theyre worse.

What do you constitute as proof? Opinion? Probably not, yet that's what you gave me. Not too many stats for OL other than games started...

_________________

Touchdown Jesus · Admin Posts: 2076 Join date: 2008-08-21

SoxNats09 wrote:

Touchdown Jesus wrote:

SoxNats09 wrote:

They were just examples, I could go on... do you want me to?

yes and instead of just naming off random players (which anyone can do) actually give proof that theyre worse.

What do you constitute as proof? Opinion? Probably not, yet that's what you gave me. Not too many stats for OL other than games started...

the only person I gave an opinion for was for McKinnie, so I dont know what you're talking about. I used facts for reasoning in the other ones, facts are not opinion.

_________________